This ran on Wednesday,
August 13, 2003 in the East Valley Tribune:
For whom the police whistle blows
Civil authorities must take great
care to avoid slippery slope of less and less tolerance
We are the five peace activists who were cited by the Mesa Police
Department on August 5 for chalking body silhouettes on Mesa public
sidewalks. The chalking was a part of the Shadow Project, an international
effort to memorialize the victims of the first atomic bomb dropped
in Hiroshima, Japan on August 6, 1945. Two hundred thousand people
died as a result of that bomb – many were simply vaporized
leaving only their shadow on sidewalks and walls.
Activists have carried out the Shadow Project across the Phoenix
Valley since 1982. Never before has anyone been cited or arrested.
Not until August 5, 2003.
On that night the City of Mesa wasted valuable tax dollars by sending
in a swarm of police vehicles and uniformed officers to confront
and cite us. They wasted even more by sending a city fire truck
and crew to wash the chalk from the sidewalks – a job that
could have easily been done with a garden hose or even a bucket
of water.
We’re trained in nonviolence and conflict resolution and respectfully
explained to police officers what our actions were and what they
meant. But they weren’t open to listening.
Even so, it’s now official. The graffiti charges against the
five of us have been dismissed. The Mesa Police Department has apologized
and has admitted that they “over-reacted”. The Department
has acknowledged that we have the right to protest…the right
to be in the streets…and the right to dissent. And Mesa Police
have pledged to be there in the future to protect our right to speak
out.
We’re pleased with this small victory. But here’s the
bigger picture.
What happened to us in Mesa on August 5 is a direct reflection of
the diminishing civil rights of all Americans. Since 9-11, Americans
have stood silently by and watched as our civil rights have been
systematically taken away from us. We have collectively bought into
the notion that we must relinquish these rights in the name of national
security.
Those of us who were cited by the Mesa Police were willing to stand
up, speak out, and demand recognition of our right to dissent. And
thanks to the Arizona Civil Liberties Union and to courageous local
attorneys such as Marty Lieberman, we would have been well represented
in court.
The fact that the Mesa Police Department recognized its error and
recommended that the charges be dismissed doesn’t take away
the reality that the civil liberties of all Americans have been
significantly compromised. It’s time that we remember the
lesson of Lutheran Minister and Nazi concentration camp survivor
Martin Niemoeller.
Following the atrocities of the holocaust, Pastor Niemoeller was
asked, “How did the world let this happen?” He responded…First
they came for the Communists, and I didn’t speak up because
I wasn’t a Communist. Then they came for the Jews, and I didn’t
speak up because I wasn’t a Jew. Then they came for the trade
unionists, and I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a
trade unionist. Then they came for the Catholics and I didn’t
speak up because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me, and
by that time there was no one left to speak up!
Niemoeller’s story has important implications for us today
in the United States. This is the important lesson to take from
the recent incident between peace activists and City of Mesa police
officers. Not only do we as American citizens have the right to
stand up and speak out – we have the responsibility to do
so in defense of each other and of our constitutionally protected
civil rights.
If we as a nation don’t do it soon,
who will be left to speak up for you?
Special To The Tribune from "The Mesa
Five":
Amy Shinabarger
Mitch Rubin
Danielle Hagerty
Pam Garrison
Sherry Bohlen
|